In mid-2006 a second fan tribute album was completed. Entitled "We're Going To Stop Pretending That We Didn't Break Your Songs", the album features members of the now-dead message board "Jeannie's Diary" performing Eels songs in unique ways.

Tracklist:

1. Wizzzardthe1 - A Magic World
2. Stijn - Mr. E's Beautiful Blues
3. Everything Is Changing - Cheater's Guide
4. Monster Trucker (feat. The Blisters) - Cancer For The Cure
5. Tehdai - That's Not Really Funny
6. Elizabeth & Emily - Fresh Feeling
7. Joost & Misha - I Like Birds
8. Mono and the Blisters - Spunky
9. The Sad Clown - My Beloved Monster
10. Alepopale - Packing Blankets
11. Mr. Butterfly - The Good Old Days
12. Mr. G (feat. Sjaakie) - What Is This Note?
13. GreatMistake (feat. Stijn) - Guest List
14. Sadie - Songs That Make You Not Wanna Die (medley)
15. Cédric - Dead Of Winter
16. The Organ Gang - Manchild
17. Jeannie and The Diaries - I Want To Protect You

Artwork designed by Maple Tree.

In 1999, an earlier fan tribute album, organized by the Spunky2 mailing list and distributed by CD-R, was entitled, "P.S. You Rock OUR Worlds…".